How to respond to a major revision

A major revision means the editor sees a publishable paper if you fix the problems the reviewers raised. Most papers that are revised carefully are eventually accepted. The work is in being thorough and making it easy for the reviewers to see what changed.

Try the reference checker free

6 min read

Plan before you write

  1. Read the editor’s letter first

    It tells you which points matter most. Address those fully.

  2. Split the comments

    Number every point by reviewer, as a checklist.

  3. Estimate the work

    Note which points need new analysis or data and how long they take. Ask for an extension early if you need one.

  4. Agree with co-authors

    Decide who handles which point and how you will answer disagreements.

Answer every comment

  • Quote the comment, then answer it: what you changed, why, and where (section, page and line numbers).
  • Do the requested analysis where you reasonably can, even if you expect it to change little: showing it is stronger than arguing about it.
  • Mark changes in the manuscript (tracked changes or highlighting) if the journal asks.
  • Keep the tone neutral and grateful once, at the start.

When you disagree

You may decline a request. State why, with evidence, and show you took the concern seriously: add a limitation, a sentence of clarification or a robustness check that addresses the underlying worry. Write for the editor, who decides between you and the reviewer.

Before you resubmit

  • Check that line numbers in the letter match the final file.
  • Make sure every change in the letter is in the manuscript, and every change in the manuscript is in the letter.
  • Re-check references, figures and supplementary files.
  • Have someone outside the project read the revised abstract and introduction.

Questions

What are the chances of acceptance after a major revision?

Good if you address the comments thoroughly, but not guaranteed: some papers go through a second round, and some are rejected if the revision is weak.

Can I ask for more time?

Yes. Ask the editor early, explain why, and propose a date.

Is there a template for the response letter?

Use the free response-to-reviewers builder: paste the comments and it creates a point-by-point letter.