How to review a research paper
A step-by-step method
Reviewing a paper well is a skill you can learn, and it improves your own writing. This method works for journal reviews, conference reviews and reviewing a colleague’s draft.
Read it three times
- First pass: the big picture
Title, abstract, introduction, figures and conclusion. What is the question, and what is the claimed answer?
- Second pass: the evidence
Methods and results in detail. Does the design answer the question? Do the results support each claim?
- Third pass: the details
References, figures, statistics, clarity and anything missing.
What to check
- Contribution: is it new, and is the difference from the closest work clear?
- Methods: appropriate, described well enough to repeat, with suitable controls or comparisons.
- Results: do the data support the conclusions, and are uncertainties reported?
- Literature: are key and recent works cited and discussed fairly?
- Presentation: is the paper clear, and do the figures help?
Structure the report
- Summary
Two or three sentences in your own words: shows the authors you understood the paper.
- Major issues
Problems that affect the conclusions, each with why it matters and what would fix it.
- Minor issues
Clarity, small errors, missing details.
- Recommendation
For the editor, with a short justification, if the journal asks for one.
Tone
Review the paper, not the authors. Be specific, suggest fixes, and acknowledge what works. A good review is one the authors can act on, even if the decision is to reject.
Questions
Can students review papers?
Often yes, with a supervisor (co-review) or for student journals and conferences. Ask your supervisor; many journals welcome early-career reviewers.
Can I use AI to review a paper I was sent?
Check the journal’s policy first. Many forbid uploading confidential manuscripts to AI tools.