Common reviewer comments

How to answer them

Reviewers in every field ask a small set of recurring questions. Knowing them lets you answer them in the paper before submission, and reply well when they appear in a review.

Try the pre-submission review free

7 min read

The comments, and what they mean

  1. “The novelty is unclear.”

    The reviewer cannot see what is new compared with the closest work. Name that work and state the difference in one sentence.

  2. “The sample size is small.”

    Justify it (a power analysis, the population size, or a precision target) and state the limitation.

  3. “The methods are not described in enough detail.”

    Add what someone would need to repeat the study: materials, settings, procedures, analysis code or software versions.

  4. “The conclusions are not supported by the results.”

    Remove or soften claims that go beyond the data; separate what you found from what you think it implies.

  5. “Important literature is missing.”

    Add and discuss the cited work, especially recent papers. If you left something out deliberately, say why.

  6. “The statistics are inappropriate.”

    Check assumptions, report effect sizes and intervals, and correct for multiple comparisons where needed.

  7. “The paper is hard to follow.”

    Restructure around the research question; one idea per paragraph; define terms once.

  8. “The limitations are not discussed.”

    Add a short, honest limitations paragraph and what future work could address.

How to reply in the response letter

  • Thank the reviewer once, then answer each point directly: what changed and where.
  • If you disagree, give evidence, not opinion, and address the underlying concern another way.
  • Quote short pieces of new text so the reviewer does not have to search for it.

Questions

Are reviewer comments similar across fields?

The topics are: novelty, methods, evidence, literature, clarity and limitations. The details differ, such as reporting guidelines in medicine or identification in economics.

Can I prevent these comments?

Many of them. Answer each question in the paper before you submit; a pre-submission review shows which ones apply to your draft.