Common reviewer comments
How to answer them
Reviewers in every field ask a small set of recurring questions. Knowing them lets you answer them in the paper before submission, and reply well when they appear in a review.
The comments, and what they mean
- “The novelty is unclear.”
The reviewer cannot see what is new compared with the closest work. Name that work and state the difference in one sentence.
- “The sample size is small.”
Justify it (a power analysis, the population size, or a precision target) and state the limitation.
- “The methods are not described in enough detail.”
Add what someone would need to repeat the study: materials, settings, procedures, analysis code or software versions.
- “The conclusions are not supported by the results.”
Remove or soften claims that go beyond the data; separate what you found from what you think it implies.
- “Important literature is missing.”
Add and discuss the cited work, especially recent papers. If you left something out deliberately, say why.
- “The statistics are inappropriate.”
Check assumptions, report effect sizes and intervals, and correct for multiple comparisons where needed.
- “The paper is hard to follow.”
Restructure around the research question; one idea per paragraph; define terms once.
- “The limitations are not discussed.”
Add a short, honest limitations paragraph and what future work could address.
How to reply in the response letter
- Thank the reviewer once, then answer each point directly: what changed and where.
- If you disagree, give evidence, not opinion, and address the underlying concern another way.
- Quote short pieces of new text so the reviewer does not have to search for it.
Questions
Are reviewer comments similar across fields?
The topics are: novelty, methods, evidence, literature, clarity and limitations. The details differ, such as reporting guidelines in medicine or identification in economics.
Can I prevent these comments?
Many of them. Answer each question in the paper before you submit; a pre-submission review shows which ones apply to your draft.