Response to reviewers
Free point-by-point letter builder
Editors read a response letter to see, quickly, that every comment was taken seriously. Paste the comments below: the builder splits them by reviewer and number, gives each a reply box and a “where it changed” field, and assembles the letter as you type.
Response to reviewers Dear Editor and Reviewers, Thank you for the careful reading of our manuscript and for the constructive comments. We have revised the manuscript to address each point. Below, the reviewers’ comments are reproduced in full, followed by our response and the location of each change in the revised manuscript. We hope the revised manuscript is now suitable for publication, and we would be glad to address any further questions. Sincerely, [Corresponding author, on behalf of all authors]
Saved in this browser only. Nothing is sent to NoveltyAxis.
How to write a response the editor will accept
- Answer every comment, in order, even the small ones. A missed comment reads as a dismissed one.
- Start each reply with what you did, then why. “We added a power analysis (Section 2.4)” beats a paragraph of explanation.
- Point to the exact place: section, page and line numbers of the revised manuscript.
- Quote the new or changed text when it is short, so the reviewer does not have to look for it.
- Thank reviewers once at the start, not in every reply.
When you disagree with a reviewer
You can decline a request. Say so plainly, give the reason with evidence (a citation, a result, a constraint of the design), and, where you can, show that you addressed the underlying concern another way, for example by adding a limitation to the discussion.
Never argue with the reviewer’s competence. Write for the editor, who decides.
Before you send it
- Check that the line numbers match the final revised file.
- Make sure every change mentioned in the letter is in the manuscript, and the other way round.
- Re-check the reference list: new citations added in revision are a common source of errors.
Questions
Is my text uploaded anywhere?
No. The builder runs in your browser. Your draft is saved only in this browser so you can come back to it.
How does it split the comments?
Lines like “Reviewer 2” start a new reviewer; numbered lines (1., 2), Comment 3:) or blank lines start a new comment. You can edit the pasted text to fix any split.
Should I respond to the editor’s comments too?
Yes. Paste them first under a heading such as “Reviewer 1” renamed to “Editor”, or answer them at the top of the letter.