Pre-submission review
Find what a reviewer will flag, before you submit
A pre-submission review reads your draft the way a journal reviewer or thesis examiner will, so you can fix the problems while they are still cheap to fix. NoveltyAxis gives you a fix list where every point quotes your own text, an independent reviewer report, a check of every reference, the closest published work and journals that publish papers like yours.
- Works on
- PDF or Word (.docx): journal manuscripts, conference papers, thesis chapters
- Fields
- Any field, sciences, social sciences and humanities
- Time
- Usually 15 to 60 minutes; we email you when it is ready
- Price
- Free to start; paid plans from $5 a month; reference checks always free
What the pre-submission review checks
- A fix list, most serious first. Every point quotes the passage in your draft it is about, so you can find it and judge it yourself.
- Reviewer reports scored on a rubric: contribution, soundness, clarity and fit. Paid modes add a second, independent reviewer.
- Every reference, looked up in Crossref, OpenAlex and arXiv: invented, mismatched and retracted entries are flagged, and citations missing from the list are found.
- Numbers in the abstract and conclusion that the body of the paper does not contain.
- Novelty: the closest published papers to yours and how your contribution differs from them.
- Where to submit: journals that publish work like yours, grouped by SCImago (SJR) quartile, with a realistic tier for this draft.
Why papers are stopped before peer review
Editors desk-reject a large share of submissions without sending them out. The usual reasons are predictable: the paper does not fit the journal, the contribution is not clear in the first page, the methods are not described well enough to judge, the references are careless, or the writing hides the result.
A pre-submission review catches most of these, because each one leaves a trace in the text. What it cannot judge is whether your field will find the question interesting; that still needs your supervisor or a colleague.
How it works
- Upload your draft
A PDF or Word file. Choose the sections you want: fix list, reviewers, references, novelty, journals.
- It reads and checks
The text is read section by section; references are looked up in public records; the closest papers are found in open scholarly indexes.
- You get a report
The fix list, reviewer reports, reference results and journal list, each point tied to a quote or a record you can open.
- Hand it to your AI agent
On paid plans, turn the report into a prompt for Claude Code, Codex, Cursor or ChatGPT that works through each fix and the experiments to run, without inventing results.
- Revise and check again
Upload the revised draft to the same review to see which problems are fixed. Free, and it does not use a run.
What it will not do
- Rewrite your paper or polish its English. The review tells you what to fix; the writing stays yours.
- Promise acceptance. It reduces avoidable rejections; the editor and reviewers still decide.
- Train on your work. Your draft is used only to produce your review.
Questions
How is this different from proofreading?
Proofreading fixes language. A pre-submission review looks at what reviewers judge: whether the claims are supported, the methods are clear, the references are real and the paper fits the journal.
Can I use it on a thesis chapter?
Yes. Upload the chapter as a PDF or Word file. The review treats it like a paper, and the reference check and novelty sections work the same way.
Is my unpublished paper safe?
Your draft is used only to produce your review and is never used to train AI models. Check your university or journal policy on AI tools before uploading confidential work.
How long does it take?
Usually 15 to 60 minutes, depending on length and the mode you choose. You can close the page; we email you when it is done.
Can an AI agent make the fixes for me?
It can do much of the work. On paid plans the finished review writes a prompt for Claude Code, Codex, Cursor or ChatGPT listing every fix with its quote and page, the experiments to run and the reviewers’ questions, with rules against invented results or citations. You check and approve every change.