Your paper was rejected
What to do next
Rejection is normal: most papers are rejected at least once before they are published. What matters is what you do in the next two weeks. This guide shows how to read the decision, decide what to change, and choose where to send the paper next.
Read the decision type first
- Desk rejection (no reviews): usually fit, scope, a contribution that is not clear on page one, or presentation. Often fixable quickly.
- Rejection after review: the reviewers found problems with the method, evidence or contribution. Read every comment before you decide anything.
- Reject and resubmit: the editor would consider a substantially revised version. Treat it as a major revision with more work.
- Transfer offer: the publisher suggests a sister journal. Consider it, but check that the journal suits your goals.
Wait a day, then sort the comments
- List every comment
Copy each reviewer and editor point into one document.
- Mark each one
Fixable now, needs new work (analysis, data, experiments), or disagreement you can answer with evidence.
- Look for patterns
If two reviewers raise the same issue, it is the real problem, whatever the wording.
- Decide the scope
Small fixes and a new journal, or a deeper revision first. Do not resubmit unchanged.
Choose the next journal carefully
Sending the same paper to a journal of the same tier and scope often brings the same outcome. If the rejection was about fit, look for journals that have published several papers like yours recently. If it was about the strength of the contribution, consider a more specialised journal or strengthen the work first.
Reformat for the new journal’s guidelines, rewrite the cover letter for its readers, and update the reference list: a paper that is a year older may need newer citations.
What not to do
- Do not appeal unless there is a clear factual error in the review; appeals rarely succeed.
- Do not submit to several journals at once.
- Do not ignore the reviewers’ points: the next journal may send it to the same people.
Questions
How common is rejection?
Very common. Many journals reject most submissions, often before review. A rejection says the paper did not fit or convince this journal now, not that it cannot be published.
Should I tell the next journal about the rejection?
Usually not required. Some journals and transfer systems let you share earlier reviews, which can speed things up if you addressed them.
How long should I wait before resubmitting?
As long as the revisions take. Resubmitting the same day without changes rarely helps.