AI peer review for economics

Economics referees focus on identification: does the design isolate the effect claimed? NoveltyAxis reviews your paper with that question first, checks references and finds the closest papers, including working papers.

Start a review

Works on
PDF or Word: papers, thesis chapters, proposals
Sources searched
arXiv, OpenAlex, Semantic Scholar and Crossref
Price
Free to start; paid plans from $5 a month; reference checks free

What reviewers in economics check

  • The identification strategy and the assumptions it relies on.
  • Robustness checks and alternative specifications.
  • Data sources, sample construction and replication materials.
  • Contribution relative to the closest papers.
  • Whether policy conclusions follow from the estimates.

Practices referees expect

  • A replication package (many journals follow the AEA data and code availability policy).
  • Pre-analysis plans for field experiments, for example in the AEA RCT Registry.

Before you write: check the idea

The novelty check searches the published record and preprint servers for the closest papers on your question.

What it does not do

  • It does not rewrite your work or polish the English.
  • It cannot judge whether your field will find the question important; your supervisor can.
  • It reads the text of your draft; it does not rerun your analysis or check raw data.

Questions

Does it check my regressions?

It reviews how the empirical strategy and results are described. It does not rerun your code.

Is my unpublished work private?

Your draft or idea is used only to produce your report and is never used to train AI models.